Show summary Hide summary
The New York Yankees opened a four-game winning streak this week just as Aaron Judge returned from a lengthy absence, a combination that instantly reshapes New York’s playoff calculus. Judge’s comeback after roughly 99 days sidelined with a stress fracture in his right rib matters because his presence fundamentally alters the Yankees’ lineup and their chances in the crowded American League race.
The 4-0 run came against the Colorado Rockies and the New York Mets, opponents that haven’t been expected to stop a championship-caliber roster — but the timing of Judge’s return is what gives the streak real significance. New York managed a respectable record while he was out, but the offense showed clear strains without its marquee slugger.
Northern Illinois 9/11 25th anniversary: schedule of local ceremonies
Aaron Judge back: Yankees surge into World Series contention
What changed while Judge was away
Even with a strong pitching staff carrying much of the load, the Yankees’ offense dipped when Judge was sidelined. New York posted a 45-39 ledger during that stretch, yet drifted farther behind the Tampa Bay Rays in the AL East.
| Player | Before Judge’s IL | During Judge’s absence |
|---|---|---|
| Cody Bellinger | ~.271 AVG, 8 HR, ~.855 OPS | ~.257 AVG, 4 HR, ~.660 OPS (missed 26 games with a hamstring issue) |
| Ben Rice | ~.306 AVG, 17 HR, ~1.056 OPS | ~.230 AVG, ~.768 OPS while appearing in nearly all games |
| Jose Caballero | ~.263 AVG, 4 HR, 14 SB, ~.705 OPS | ~.215 AVG, increased HR and SB totals but a ~.633 OPS |
The table above compresses the offensive swing: batting averages and OPS figures fell for several regulars, even as some counting stats — home runs and stolen bases — continued to accumulate. The net effect was a lineup that lacked the consistent middle-order power Judge provides.
Early signs after Judge’s return
Judge has been cautious in his first few games back, going 3-for-10 without an extra-base hit or an RBI and sitting out the Rockies’ series finale on Thursday. Still, the Yankees scored 27 runs across this week’s games, and two of their top bats—Rice and Bellinger—have shown renewed production.
Across the last four contests, Rice and Bellinger combined for a .367 average (11-for-30), three homers and six RBIs, including a pair of homers and four RBIs in Friday’s 6-4 victory over the Mets. That kind of short-term hot streak underscores how much more dangerous the lineup is with Judge healthy and other hitters contributing.
Depth and deadline pickups
New York’s rotation has been a stabilizing force while the offense recharged. The front office also added outfielder Luis Garcia Jr. at the trade deadline; since arriving from Washington he’s hit .314 with seven homers and an .886 OPS, injecting middle-order punch and giving managers more lineup flexibility.
- Rotation strength: Consistent starting pitching helped the Yankees remain competitive while Judge rehabilitated.
- Bench and trade additions: Garcia’s hot start matters now that Judge is back — the lineup has more complementary firepower.
- Health watch: Bellinger’s hamstring and Judge’s return-to-form remain key variables down the stretch.
Absent Giancarlo Stanton and Juan Soto — both major pieces of the Yankees’ recent power mix who are no longer in New York — Judge is still the linchpin. He’s not a luxury for this roster; he’s the engine that turns a solid team into a serious World Series contender.
That reality is why this week’s winning streak feels more consequential than a small sample of victories. Judge’s return doesn’t erase the season’s lingering questions, but it gives the Yankees a clearer route forward: a balanced rotation, contributions from returning and acquired bats, and the centerpiece hitter finally back in the lineup.
For fans and fantasy managers alike, the immediate implication is simple: expect the Yankees to swing back toward form with Judge’s presence, while monitoring the team’s health and whether the recent offensive uptick sustains into September and the postseason.
